SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The unwanted were turned away from cafeteria
tables. Fistfights broke out at karaoke. Dances became breeding grounds
for gossip and cruelty.
It became clear this place had a bullying
problem on its hands. What many found surprising was that the
perpetrators and victims alike were all senior citizens.
homes, senior centers and housing complexes for the elderly have
introduced programs, training and policies aimed at curbing spates of
bullying, an issue once thought the exclusive domain of the young.
the clique system just like everywhere else," said Betsy Gran, who
until recently was assistant director at San Francisco's 30th Street
Senior Center. "It's like 'Mean Girls,' but everyone is 80."
the cafeteria exiles and karaoke brouhahas, the 30th Street Center
teamed up with a local nonprofit, the Institute on Aging, to develop an
anti-bullying program. All staff members received 18 hours of training
that included lessons on what constitutes bullying, causes of the
problem and how to manage such conflicts. Seniors were then invited to
similar classes, held in English and Spanish, teaching them to alert
staff or intervene themselves if they witness bullying. Signs and even
place mats around the center now declare it a "Bully Free Zone."
think in the past I would have just stayed out of it," said Mary
Murphy, 86, a retired real estate agent who took the classes. "Now I
might be inclined to help."
Robin Bonifas, a social work professor
at Arizona State University and author of the book "Bullying Among
Older Adults: How to Recognize and Address an Unseen Epidemic," said
existing studies suggest about 1 in 5 seniors encounters bullying. She
sees it as an outgrowth of frustrations characteristic in communal
settings, as well a reflection of issues unique to getting older. Many
elderly see their independence and sense of control disappear and, for
some, becoming a bully can feel like regaining some of that lost power.
makes them feel very out of control," Bonifas said, "and the way they
sort of get on top of things and make their name in this new world is
intimidating, picking on people, gossiping."
There is far less
recognition of bullying as a problem among seniors compared with young
people. Even among those who have been called bullies, many are unaware
how problematic their behavior is until it's labeled. Campaigns around
the country have sought to spread the word, including a booklet
circulated last year by the National Center for Assisted Living.
the life cycle, it doesn't go away," said Katherine Arnold, a member of
the city Human Rights Commission in St. Louis Park, Minnesota, which
created a public service announcement on its community-access station
that included a portrayal of a man who was excluded from a card game and
became the subject of gossip by other seniors. "There's really not a
lot of escape."
Most senior bullying isn't physical but rather
involves name-calling, rumors and exclusion, said Pamela Countouris, a
longtime schoolteacher who now runs a Pittsburgh-based consultancy that
offers training on bullying. Women constitute the bulk of the bullies
Countouris encounters among seniors, a reflection of lifespan
disparities and the gender makeup of those who live at or participate in
programs at senior facilities.
Countouris' business began with a
focus on school bullying but now centers exclusively on seniors. In the
next month alone, she has more than a dozen training sessions planned.
four years immersed in the wrath of older bullies, Countouris has heard
all manner of stories. At a senior high-rise, a woman who saw herself
as the queen of the parking garage would key the cars of those who
crossed her. Elsewhere, laundry rooms became vicious places where the
bullied had their detergent stolen and their clothes thrown on the
floor. Bingo rooms so often devolved into battlefields — with lucky
newcomers badgered and accused of cheating by veteran players — she came
to call it "the devil's game."
"I didn't realize it was an underground society where people could be mean to each other," Countouris said.
the worst cases, bullying goes far beyond bingo squabbles. Marsha
Wetzel moved into a senior apartment complex in Niles, Illinois, after
her partner of 30 years died and her partner's family evicted her from
the home the couple shared. At Glen St. Andrew Living Community, she
said she was met with relentless bullying by residents mostly focused on
her being a lesbian.
One man hit Wetzel's scooter with his walker
and unleashed a barrage of homophobic slurs. A woman rammed her
wheelchair into Wetzel's table in the dining room and knocked it over,
warning "homosexuals will burn in hell." In the mailroom, someone
knocked her in the head, and in an elevator, she was spit on.
just go in my room and barricade my door and just pray," said Wetzel,
now 70 and living at a senior complex in Chicago. "I just felt like a
slug, like I was nothing, like I wasn't even human."
which defends LGBTQ rights, took on Wetzel's case and sued Glen St.
Andrew, claiming Fair Housing Act violations. A federal judge dismissed
the suit last year. An appeals court decision is pending.
had seen such bullying throughout her life. She dropped out of high
school when she became a punching bag for the girls who learned she was a
lesbian. As a senior, she said, it felt even more traumatic — and the
bullies even more vicious. She had a view of a cemetery from her window
and would stare at it, thinking maybe only when she arrived there would
she find peace.
"I felt like a person in a pool of piranhas," she said.